Mysterious Ruin at Bluff Point
There is no trace above ground today of the elaborate, extensive, grid-patterned ruin of the Celtic-like "village" that was once situated on Bluff Point above Keuka Lake. The ruin is on Skyline Drive, about four miles south of Keuka Park, New York, which is just off Route 54-A. On the Yates County highway map, Keuka Park is marked "Site of Primitive Mound Indians." There are two mounds on Skyline Drive, one quite close to the ruin site and directly north of it.
Detailed reports of the ruin come principally from only three sources that I can find: 1) The results of a geological survey made of Yates County, New York, in 1880. 2) The results of an excavation of the site carried out in 1938 and 1939. 3) A brief report of the appearance of the site in 1954.
The geological survey was made by Dr. Samuel Hart Wright, MD, who also held an MA degree from Williams College, was a land surveyor, and an internationally recognized biologist. He was assisted by his son, Berlin Hart Wright, MD.
One of the first owners of the land, Howland Hemphill, who lived on the site for 50 years, is mentioned by Berlin Hart Wright: "Mr. Hemphill was an aged man at the time of our survey. He said he came to the farm as a young man when the Indians were all about. In answer to a question...he was informed that. ..(the ruin)... was there when the earliest tribesman came to the region."
The 1938-1939 excavation by many persons was carried out under the direction of a newspaper reporter from Canandaigua, New York, Mr. Gilbert T. Brewer.
The general appearance of the site did not seem to have changed much from 1880 until as recently as 1954 when the author A. Glenn Rogers visited there and wrote a brief account of it. I am sorry to report that by 1985, and probably a decade or two earlier, the above ground remnants of the site had been almost completely obliterated by vineyards, drainage ditches, hay fields, farm work roads and a pine plantation. Inside the pine plantation are two or three shallow depressions with several mounds of earth next to them, probably all the remains of the 1938-1939 excavation.
The schematic ground plan of the site made from the 1880 land survey covers 13 acres of the ruin. The ruin was usually described as being between 14 and 20 acres in extent. The plan shows seven principal walls running roughly NW - SE, one short wall running N - S, and 12 principal walls running roughly NE - SW.
At the time the survey was made, Dr. Wright reports that the land in Lot 5 (the northern five acres) shown on the plan had been plowed, and some detail there was surmised by the Wrights from surface rocks. The southern eight acres (in Lot 6) had never been plowed, was unforested, and much detail was visible, as is obvious from the plan and from written reports.
Among other things, the 1880s plan shows ten "rooms" that, had they been roofed over, might have been dwellings or storage rooms, generally about 30 x 40 feet or slightly larger. There are also four still larger "rooms" that might have been enclosures, for what, is unknown, and two enclosed areas that might have been for ceremonial purposes. One of the latter might have been a large antechamber. The other seems to have enclosed two stone circles each with a diameter of about 30 feet, and a segment of a third circle of similar size. Most of the rest of the ruin seems to have consisted of walls which might have enclosed fields. Except for their size and regularity, the "fields" are not unlike prehistoric and medieval farming fields, consisting of long, relatively narrow strips separated by stone walls. English archeologists call such fields "Celtic Fields." No one had reported burials in connection with the site.
An account written by Berlin Hart Wright in 1880, or shortly thereafter, states in part, "The remains of the ancient structure consisted of the foundations of the walls, in the form of graded ways three to eight feet wide and one to two feet high, bordered with a vast number of large, flat stones set in the ground edgeways, these stones leaning inward toward the center of the ways. At points of intersection of some of the walls, depressions indicated posts had been standing there at one time, evidently supporting a roof."
Dr. Wright's account published in the 1884 Thirty Fifth Annual Report of the New York State Museum of Natural History, by the Regents of the University, pages 193 and 194 states: "All the areas between these ways are depressions, in which water remains until evaporated, the nearness of the rock below, often being only twelve or fourteen inches, prevented its absorption. These areas, or many of them, contain bogs of carex, and some grass, but in the summer are dry and afford a fair pasturage. The dirt used to make the ways was taken from these areas causing the depressions, and the rock beneath was no doubt at that time completely laid bare and furnished the flat stones that are set in on each side of the graded ways.. .No trees are in the structure exept a few young ones."
A. Glenn Rogers in his book Forgotten Stories of The Finger Lakes, published in 1954, gives a description of what he saw of the stone and earth works at the Bluff Point Site in 1954: "...these queer stone formations are still clearly outlined. The ruins are comprised of well-arranged stone floors and slab hedgerows. The stones dividing the sections are well cut, resembling small slabs, and are placed in the ground at an angle, not upright... The construction of a parallel ridge of stones is most peculiar. They are raised 12 to 18 inches above the surface, and faced along the sides with flat stones."
In the 1960s when telephone lines were buried along Skyline Drive, the telephone company's ditching machine exposed one of the walls. The landowner's description of the obstruction tallies exactly with the "graded ways" described by Rogers and the Wrights.
Before going further, I would like to add that the description by the Wrights and A. Glenn Rogers depicts all that is usually left today of one type of ancient European dwelling. I have seen dozens of ancient wall bases in the English Lake District that coincide with the Wright-Rogers descriptions above, except that they are circular and are narrower. A good sketch of the foundation of an intact dwelling may be seen in T. Clare's Archeological sites of the Lake District (published in 1981). On page 21 he mentions "...the circular hut, although rectangular buildings can also be present." and further states these foundation walls "...do not belong to a single period but are found from the Bronze Age to the post Roman period."
There are only two drawings of other sites that I can find that look somewhat similar to the wall plan shown of the Bluff Point Site, although neither shows such an elaborate site. Both drawings are on Page 68 of The Druids by Stuart Piggott, published in 1968. One is labeled "Angular ditched enclosures and graves, late pre-Roman, at Wallertheim, Rheinhessen:" And the other as being ".. .of the Roman period against the Roman road at Bokerly Dyke, Hampshire." Other illustrations in the book make it apparent that Celts made much use of square and rectangular structures involving earth banks and ditches.
Mr. David B. Kelley's Pre-Colonial Earthen & Stone Ruins in Yates County, New York dated March 12, 1981, and updated on January 1, 1988, shows that there was a determined effort made in 1938 and 1939 by Canandaigua, New York, newspaper reporter, Gilbert T. Brewer and several others to excavate the site.
They found: "Bedrock quarried to a depth of 10 feet; arches were of sandstone, the bases of which were set into the cut bedrock; stones engraved with human and animal heads, along with iron objects with similar ornamentation; one iron object with 'granular' ornamentation and another with a red enamel design; broken metal platter; a metal detector indicated the presence of stoneware including hammers, pounders, polishers, mortars and pestles, and fragments of a 'seal'; among the images of humans, that of a woman was the most frequent." Mr. Brewer is said to have thought "that the engraved stone images were similar to the images found in paintings in Etruscan tombs. He also thought that the iron implements were similar to those known to be of Nordic origin."
Some, not all, of the artifacts found during the 1938 - 1939 excavation certainly appear to have been of European origin. But the "Gil. Brewer Collection" seems to have dropped out of sight. An article in a St. Petersburg, Florida, newspaper in 1952 refers to him as "the late Mr. Brewer," and I can find no indication of his movements, or his collection, after October 15, 1939.
What Was The Purpose and Who Built